Plant Biochemistry, Box
124, Lund University, SE-221 00 Lund,
Sweden
title:
Hypothetico-deductive science and the function of
cytoplasmic genomes
In chloroplasts
and mitochondria, small, quasi-autonomous,
cytoplasmic genomes encode core components of
energy transduction in photosynthesis and
respiration, together with genetic systems that
permit the quasi-autonomy. From sequence
information alone, there seems to be no clue to the
function of this costly arrangement - each
chloroplast or mitochondrial gene requires a set of
nuclear genes to oversee its function. Why has the
cell nucleus not acquired all the genes derived
from the original endosymbiosis? Genomes must
function and be regulated. Their continuity
requires regulatory input. I propose that the
structural genes retained in chloroplasts and
mitochondria receive such input in situ, from the
redox chemistry of the energy transduction in which
their gene products participate. The same genes may
have been readily copied to the cell nucleus to
produce functional and importable protein
precursors, but they would there escape this vital
regulatory control. This conjecture has many ways
in which it might be refuted, but the functional
genomics of chloroplasts and mitochondria seem to
be consistent with its predictions. Implications
arise for ageing and the function and evolution of
separate sexes. In addition, we may conclude that
gene function requires evolutionary continuity, and
we cannot therefore understand functional
significance ab initio. I suggest that the idea of
a purely automated, deductive route to knowledge
and understanding has much in common with the
doctrine of spontaneous generation, and about the
same utility.
http://plantcell.lu.se/john/pres/
|